Safeguarding Reviews: Learning and Strengthening Practice

About this episode:

What makes a safeguarding review genuinely effective? Sam Preston and Sara Spinks explore how schools can move beyond blame to build a culture of learning, reflection and continuous improvement. From chronologies and professional curiosity to information sharing, leadership and governance, discover how meaningful review can strengthen practice and help protect children.

Authors: Sam Preston & Sara Spinks

Publish date: 22 Nov 2026

Episode script

Information discussed in this podcast was correct at the time of recording.

Sara:

Hello and welcome to another episode of Safeguarding Conversations. Today we're looking at safeguarding reviews. Sam, when we talk about safeguarding, we quite rightly focus heavily on prevention. But I know from articles you've written , you make the point that reviewing how well our safeguarding arrangements actually work is just as important. Why?

Sam:

Because good safeguarding provision really has two sides. The first is preventative. It's about having strong policies and procedures, well-trained staff, effective recording and management of concerns, appropriate early intervention and a culture where everyone understands their safeguarding responsibilities. But the second is making sure those arrangements actually work in practice. And that's where review comes in.

Sara:

So we're not just talking about reviewing safeguarding after something has gone seriously wrong?

Sam:

No, absolutely not. Review should be part of the normal safeguarding cycle. Schools should be looking at aspects of their safeguarding practice throughout the academic year and asking: Are our arrangements effective? Are procedures being followed? Are staff confident about what they need to do? Are there areas we could strengthen? But there are also occasions where something happens that should prompt a much more focused review.

Sara:

And presumably a serious safeguarding incident would be one of those occasions.

Sam:

Yes. Despite everyone's best efforts, serious incidents can still happen. There may be a significant allegation involving a member of staff. There could be serious child-on-child abuse, a significant online safety incident, concerns about information sharing, or repeated concerns that suggest something within the wider safeguarding system isn't working as well as it should. And when something significant does happen, the quality of the school's response afterwards is really important.

Sara:

I think the word "review" can sometimes make people quite nervous, though. It can sound as if somebody is coming in to find fault or decide who was responsible.

Sam:

And that's exactly what a good safeguarding review shouldn't be. Its purpose isn't to find somebody to blame. The fundamental questions are: What happened? Why did it happen? What information was available? How were decisions made? Did our safeguarding arrangements work as intended? And what can we learn from this? That's a very different approach.

Sara:

So essentially it's about learning rather than blame.

Sam:

Exactly. Because if people become defensive or frightened about admitting that something could have been done differently, you lose one of the most valuable opportunities for organisational learning. A strong safeguarding culture has to be capable of honest reflection.

Sara:

If a school decides that a safeguarding incident does warrant a review, where would you start?

Sam:

With the chronology. You need a clear and accurate picture of what happened and when. When did concerns first emerge? What was recorded? Who knew what and when? What decisions were made? What information was available to the people making those decisions? Were referrals made? Was information shared appropriately? You're effectively reconstructing the safeguarding journey.

Sara:

But there's a danger there, isn't there, of looking back knowing how the story eventually ended and thinking the answer should always have been obvious?

Sam:

Absolutely. Hindsight is one of the biggest challenges in any review. You have to consider decisions in the context in which they were actually made. What did that member of staff or DSL know at that point in time? But equally, that doesn't mean we stop questioning. We still need to ask whether professional curiosity was demonstrated. Were appropriate questions asked? Were all the available pieces of information considered together? Was there anything else that reasonably could or should have been done?

Sara:

And I assume you need to look beyond the individual decision as well.

Sam:

Very much so. Safeguarding incidents rarely come down to one isolated action. You might need to look at the school's policy and whether it reflected current requirements. You might examine recording practice, referrals, information sharing, communication with parents where appropriate, risk assessments, leadership oversight and staff training. You also need to consider whether the DSL had the information and systems needed to maintain effective oversight.

Sara:

And potentially other areas such as attendance, mental health or online safety?

Sam:

Exactly. Safeguarding doesn't operate in neat little boxes. A child's attendance, behaviour, mental health, online experiences, relationships with peers, home circumstances and additional needs can all form part of the wider safeguarding picture. That's why a review needs to look at the child and their experience as a whole, rather than simply examining one incident in isolation.

Sara:

What about information sharing? Because that seems to come up repeatedly when serious incidents are looked at.

Sam:

It does, and that's why it deserves particular attention. A review should consider what information was known by different people and agencies, how effectively that information was shared and whether anyone had enough of the overall picture to recognise the level or pattern of concern. Sometimes individual pieces of information may appear relatively insignificant on their own. Put together, they can tell a very different story.

Sara:

So professional curiosity becomes really important again.

Sam:

Absolutely. Safeguarding isn't simply about recording information. It's about asking what that information might mean. Does this fit with what we already know? Is there a pattern developing? Is something changing? Do we need further information? Do we need to challenge or escalate a decision? Those are important questions in day-to-day safeguarding, and they're equally important when reviewing practice.

Sara:

What role should senior leaders have in the review?

Sam:

Headteachers and senior leaders need to make sure the process is objective, open and properly focused on learning. At the same time, they have to be careful not to interfere with any police investigation, disciplinary process, local authority enquiry or other external process that may be under way. And there may be circumstances where independence is important. If senior leaders themselves were closely involved in the decisions being examined, bringing in an independent reviewer can provide greater impartiality and assurance.

Sara:

And governors or trustees?

Sam:

Their role is different. They shouldn't be stepping into the DSL's role or becoming involved in operational safeguarding decisions. Their responsibility is strategic assurance. They need to be confident that appropriate safeguarding arrangements are in place, that lessons from significant events are taken seriously and that agreed improvements are actually implemented. Because there's little value in producing a beautifully written safeguarding review that then sits in a folder.

Sara:

That's an important point. What should happen once the review itself is finished?

Sam:

The learning has to turn into action. Recommendations should be practical and proportionate. They need to be clear about what needs to change, who is responsible for it and how the school will know that the change has actually happened and made a difference. That might mean strengthening staff training, changing a policy, improving record keeping, reviewing referral arrangements, improving information sharing or changing leadership oversight. The important thing is that the action addresses the learning.

Sara:

And then presumably we review again?

Sam:

Exactly. Simply implementing an action doesn't automatically mean you've solved the problem. If a review identifies that staff need additional training, for example, delivering the training isn't the end point. Later, leaders need to ask whether practice has actually improved. That's what continuous improvement looks like.

Sara:

There's another side to serious safeguarding incidents that perhaps isn't discussed enough, and that's the impact on the adults involved.

Sam:

I completely agree. Critical incidents can put enormous pressure on DSLs, senior leaders and other staff. They may be supporting a child and family, managing communication with agencies, continuing their normal responsibilities and at the same time questioning decisions they themselves have made. So alongside reviewing systems and practice, schools also need to think about appropriate support for the people involved. A learning culture works best when people feel able to be open and honest.

Sara:

And where does an internal school review sit if the circumstances are so serious that an external safeguarding process is taking place?

Sam:

That's an important distinction. Where a child has died or suffered serious harm and abuse or neglect is known or suspected, the school will need to work with the relevant safeguarding partners and cooperate fully with any external review process. The school's own reflection should support that process, not duplicate or cut across it.

Sara:

So if we bring all of that together, what characterises a really effective safeguarding review?

Sam:

I'd say honesty, evidence and action. Be honest about what happened. Base conclusions on the evidence and the information that was available. And then make sure the learning leads to meaningful change. Because safeguarding systems can always be strengthened. Good organisations aren't those that pretend nothing ever goes wrong. They're organisations that are prepared to learn, challenge themselves and improve.

Sara:

And ultimately that brings us back to why we review safeguarding in the first place.

Sam:

Exactly. A review can't undo the harm caused by a serious incident. But it can help make safeguarding arrangements stronger. It can improve staff confidence and professional practice, strengthen leadership and governance, and most importantly, help us better protect children in the future.

Sara:

And perhaps that's the message to finish with.

Sam:

Safeguarding review shouldn't only happen when something has gone wrong. It's part of a healthy safeguarding culture: checking that what we've put in place is actually working, being prepared to ask difficult questions and making improvements when they're needed. I hope you've enjoyed today's episode and dont forget you can submit your safeguarding questions to the team for our monthly Q&A session, which will be published on the last Monday of every month. You can submit question at https://ssslearning.co.uk/podcastsquestions or visit our website resources tab & hit podcasts. Thanks for listening.